Why Would a Colonist Prefer to Be a Patriot Rather Than a Loyalist?


During the American Revolution, colonists had to make a crucial decision: whether to support the rebellion against British rule and become patriots or to remain loyal to the British Crown and become loyalists. This decision was influenced by various factors, including political, economic, and social considerations. In this article, we will explore the reasons why a colonist might choose to be a patriot rather than a loyalist, highlighting the key factors that motivated their decision.

1. Desire for Independence and Self-Government

The desire for independence and self-government was a significant factor that drove many colonists to become patriots. They believed in the principles of liberty, equality, and the right to govern themselves. By choosing to support the rebellion, they aimed to establish a new nation where they could have control over their own affairs.

1.1 Belief in Natural Rights

Patriots firmly believed in the concept of natural rights, which are inherent to all individuals and cannot be taken away by any government or ruler. They viewed the British Crown as infringing upon their natural rights, such as the rights to life, liberty, and property. By becoming patriots, they sought to protect and secure these fundamental rights.

1.2 Opposition to British Tyranny

The colonists who chose to be patriots perceived the British government as oppressive and tyrannical. They resented the imposition of unfair taxes, such as the Stamp Act and the Tea Act, without their consent. They also objected to the presence of British troops in their towns and the lack of representation in the British Parliament. Becoming patriots was a way for them to resist this perceived tyranny.

2. Economic Motivations

Economic considerations also played a significant role in the decision to become a patriot rather than a loyalist.

2.1 Desire for Trade and Economic Freedom

Colonists who sought trade and economic freedom were more inclined to support the rebellion. They believed that by breaking away from British rule, they could establish their own economic policies and engage in international trade without restrictions imposed by the British government. They saw the potential for economic growth and prosperity in an independent nation.

2.2 Resentment of Economic Exploitation

Loyalists were often associated with the British elite and merchants who benefited from the existing economic system. Many colonists, on the other hand, felt exploited by British policies that favored British merchants and restricted colonial economic opportunities. By becoming patriots, they hoped to break free from this economic exploitation and create a fairer economic system.

3. Social Factors

Social factors also influenced the choice between being a patriot or a loyalist.

3.1 Influence of Revolutionary Ideals

The spread of revolutionary ideals, such as liberty, equality, and democracy, had a significant impact on colonists. These ideals were often discussed in public forums, pamphlets, and newspapers, inspiring many individuals to support the rebellion. The social pressure to align with these ideals and be part of the revolutionary movement pushed many colonists to become patriots.

3.2 Fear of Social Stigma

Choosing to be a loyalist could lead to social ostracism and even violence from patriots. In some cases, loyalists were seen as traitors to their fellow colonists and faced hostility within their communities. This fear of social stigma and the desire to maintain social standing motivated some colonists to become patriots, even if they had reservations about the rebellion.

4. Family and Local Influences

Family and local influences played a crucial role in shaping colonists’ loyalties during the American Revolution.

4.1 Influence of Family Ties

Family ties and connections often played a significant role in determining whether a colonist would become a patriot or a loyalist. If a colonist’s family members or close relatives were patriots, they were more likely to join the rebellion to maintain family unity and support their loved ones.

4.2 Influence of Local Community

The local community also exerted a strong influence on colonists’ choices. In some regions, the majority of the population supported the rebellion, creating social pressure for individuals to align with the patriot cause. Conversely, in areas with a significant loyalist presence, individuals may have felt compelled to remain loyal to avoid isolation or potential reprisals.

5. Political Aspirations

Political aspirations were another reason why some colonists chose to be patriots rather than loyalists.

5.1 Desire for Political Participation

Patriots believed in the importance of political participation and representation. They saw the rebellion as an opportunity to establish a government that would allow them to have a voice in decision-making. By becoming patriots, they hoped to shape the future of the new nation and contribute to its political development.

5.2 Opposition to Monarchy and Aristocracy

Many colonists who became patriots opposed the idea of monarchy and aristocracy. They believed that political power should be distributed among the people, not concentrated in the hands of a few privileged individuals. By supporting the rebellion, they aimed to establish a government based on republican ideals and eliminate the influence of monarchs and aristocrats.

6. Military Considerations

The military aspect of the American Revolution also played a role in colonists’ decision to become patriots.

6.1 Defense of Homeland

Patriots felt a strong sense of attachment to their homeland and were willing to defend it against what they perceived as foreign aggression. They saw the British troops as invaders and sought to protect their homes, families, and communities from external threats. By joining the patriot forces, they could contribute to the defense of their homeland.

6.2 Recruitment and Rewards

The patriot cause often offered incentives to those who joined the rebellion, such as land grants, enlistment bonuses, and the promise of future rewards. These incentives motivated some colonists to become patriots, especially those who saw an opportunity for personal gain or advancement through military service.

7. Religious Factors

Religious considerations influenced the choice between being a patriot or a loyalist for some colonists.

7.1 Sermons and Religious Justifications

Religious leaders played a crucial role in shaping colonists’ opinions on the Revolution. Many sermons preached in churches emphasized the biblical principles of liberty, justice, and equality, aligning them with the patriot cause. These religious justifications resonated with individuals who saw the rebellion as a righteous struggle against oppression.

7.2 Denominational Divisions

Denominational differences also influenced colonists’ loyalties. Some religious groups, such as the Quakers, were more inclined to remain neutral or support the loyalist cause due to their pacifist beliefs. Other denominations, such as the Congregationalists, were more likely to support the patriot cause. Religious affiliations and divisions within communities played a role in determining whether individuals became patriots or loyalists.

8. Enlightenment Ideas

Enlightenment ideas and philosophy had a profound impact on the colonists and influenced their decision to become patriots.

8.1 Influence of Enlightenment Thinkers

Enlightenment thinkers, such as John Locke and Thomas Paine, advocated for individual rights, limited government, and the consent of the governed. Their ideas resonated with many colonists who saw the British government’s actions as a violation of these principles. By becoming patriots, they sought to establish a government that respected and protected these Enlightenment ideals.

8.2 Spread of Enlightenment Literature

The spread of Enlightenment literature, such as pamphlets and essays, played a crucial role in shaping colonists’ opinions. Works like Thomas Paine’s “Common Sense” presented compelling arguments for independence and rallied support for the patriot cause. The accessibility of these writings contributed to the spread of revolutionary ideas and motivated individuals to become patriots.

9. Long-Term Vision

Lastly, many colonists who chose to be patriots had a long-term vision for the future of the American colonies.

9.1 Hope for a Better Society

Patriots believed that by breaking away from British rule, they could create a better society based on their own principles and values. They envisioned a nation that valued individual freedoms, equal opportunities, and democratic governance. By supporting the rebellion, they hoped to lay the foundation for a society that would benefit future generations.

9.2 Legacy of Independence

The concept of independence held great significance for many colonists. They saw it as their duty to secure independence not only for themselves but also for future generations. By becoming patriots, they aimed to establish a legacy of independence and self-determination that would inspire others around the world.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

FAQ 1: Did all colonists have to choose between being patriots or loyalists?

No, not all colonists had to choose between being patriots or loyalists. Some individuals remained neutral or tried to stay out of the conflict altogether. Others may have initially supported one side but later switched their allegiance based on changing circumstances or personal beliefs.

FAQ 2: Were there any advantages to being a loyalist?

Being a loyalist had certain advantages, such as the protection and support of the British military and government. Loyalists also had access to resources and opportunities that were denied to patriots. However, these advantages often came at the cost of social ostracism and potential reprisals from patriots.

FAQ 3: Did all patriots support the rebellion for the same reasons?

No, patriots had diverse motivations for supporting the rebellion. While some were driven by political ideals and the desire for independence, others were primarily motivated by economic considerations or personal grievances against the British government. The patriot movement encompassed a wide range of perspectives and motivations.

FAQ 4: Were there any conflicts within patriot communities?

Yes, there were conflicts and disagreements within patriot communities. Differences in political ideology, economic interests, and regional loyalties sometimes led to tensions and divisions among patriots. However, the common goal of achieving independence generally united them despite these internal conflicts.

FAQ 5: Did the choice between being a patriot or a loyalist have long-lasting consequences?

Yes, the choice between being a patriot or a loyalist had long-lasting consequences for individuals and their families. Loyalists who remained in the newly independent United States often faced social and economic hardships, including the loss of property and legal rights. Some loyalists chose to leave the country and relocate to other parts of the British Empire.

FAQ 6: Did the American Revolution change the social and political landscape of the colonies?

Yes, the American Revolution had a profound impact on the social and political landscape of the colonies. It led to the establishment of the United States as an independent nation and the adoption of a new system of government based on republican principles. The revolution also brought about social changes, such as the abolition of slavery in some northern states and the expansion of political rights for certain groups.

FAQ 7: How did the American Revolution influence other independence movements around the world?

The American Revolution served as an inspiration for other independence movements around the world. The success of the revolution demonstrated that it was possible for a colonized people to overthrow a colonial power and establish an independent nation. The ideals of liberty, equality, and self-determination espoused during the American Revolution resonated with individuals and groups fighting for independence in other parts of the world.


The decision to become a patriot rather than a loyalist during the American Revolution was influenced by a myriad of factors. From the desire for independence and self-government to economic motivations, social pressures, and political aspirations, colonists weighed various considerations before making their choice. The American Revolution not only shaped the destiny of the colonies but also had far-reaching implications for the development of democracy and the spread of revolutionary ideals around the world.

Rate article
Add a comment